nienke broeksema  hiPJ6Z0vao unsplash

Menu Engineering - Maximizing Profits Through Menu Analysis

Tillie Demetriou
23 May 2024

Welcome to the world of menu engineering, where the art of maximizing restaurant profits meets the science of culinary delight!

Picture this: you stroll into a restaurant, eagerly flipping through the menu, your eyes widening at the tantalizing descriptions and vibrant food photography. But have you ever stopped to ponder the thought, "How did they choose these particular dishes? And why are some items priced higher than others?" Well, my friend, that's where menu engineering comes into play.

Menu engineering is like a secret formula, blending the art of design, the psychology of pricing, and the science of profitability. By analyzing your restaurant menu carefully, you can strategically position your menu items, entice customers, and boost your revenue like never before.

In the world of menu engineering, food cost percentage becomes your trusty sidekick. This superhero metric helps you understand the profitability of your menu items by calculating the percentage of food cost relative to the menu price. By identifying high-profit gems and underperforming dishes, you can make informed decisions that maximize your profitability and ensure a delightful dining experience for your patrons.

Throughout this blog, we'll explore the different categories of menu engineering, including stars, plowhorses, puzzles, and even dogs (yes, we'll address those, too!). We'll uncover the secrets behind enticing menu descriptions, clever pricing strategies, and menu item placement that practically whispers, "Order me!"

Menu analysis: understanding the basics

First up in the menu engineering process is analyzing what you already have.

Menu design and layout: where art meets appetite

When it comes to your restaurant menu, design and layout are more than just aesthetics—they are powerful tools to maximize profits. Your menu's visual appeal and organization play a significant role in influencing customers' choices. 

By creating an attractive and well-organized menu, you can grab attention, stimulate appetites, and guide customers toward high-profit items. Strategic placement of these items, such as highlighting them with eye-catching graphics or positioning them strategically on the menu, can significantly impact their sales.

Pricing strategies: balancing cost and cravings

Determining the right prices for your menu items is a delicate balancing act. It involves understanding both the cost and profitability of each dish. By considering the ingredients, preparation time, and other associated costs, you can calculate the food cost percentage and set prices that ensure profitability. 

However, pricing goes beyond mere numbers. It also takes into account customer perception and market competition. Finding the optimal menu price point that aligns with your target audience's expectations and creates a perception of value is key to maximizing profits.

Menu item categorization: unveiling hidden opportunities

Not all menu items are created equal. Categorizing your menu items helps you identify the stars, the workhorses, and the underperformers on your menu. 

Popular menu items are the crowd favorites that drive sales, while high-profit menu items contribute significantly to your bottom line. By recognizing which menu items fall into these categories, you can strategically promote and highlight them to increase their visibility and sales. 

On the other hand, identifying underperforming dishes allows you to evaluate whether they need adjustments or if it's time to bid them farewell. By optimizing your menu item mix, you can maximize both popularity and profitability.

Understanding the basics of menu analysis empowers you to make informed decisions about your restaurant menu. By designing an appealing layout, strategically placing high-profit items, setting optimal prices, and categorizing your menu items, you lay the foundation for menu engineering success.

Sign up to our newsletter

By submitting your details you agree to our terms and conditions & privacy policy.

The four menu engineering categories: unleashing the menu mavericks

Let’s dive into the exciting world of menu engineering categories! Just like a casting director assembling a stellar cast, your menu consists of four unique categories: Stars, Plowhorses, Puzzles, and Dogs.

In this section, we'll step into the menu engineering matrix and explore these menu mavericks, their characteristics, and how to harness their potential to maximize your restaurant's profitability. So, grab your popcorn and prepare for a menu analysis adventure like no other!

Stars: the celebrities of your menu

Lights, camera, action! Stars are the A-listers on your menu—the dishes that steal the show and make your customers' taste buds dance with joy. If we're talking about menu item popularity... These are the Regina George's of the menu world.

These culinary superstars are not only incredibly popular but also highly profitable menu items. They bring in a significant portion of your revenue and leave customers raving about their unforgettable flavors. So, roll out the red carpet and give these dishes the spotlight they deserve. 

Promote them with mouthwatering descriptions, visually enticing images, and strategic placement to ensure they shine brighter than ever before.

Plowhorses: the reliable workhorses

Meet the unsung heroes of your menu—the plowhorses. These dishes may not receive the same attention as the stars, but they're the backbone of your restaurant's success. 

Plowhorses are reliable and consistently perform well in terms of sales. They have a loyal following and contribute to a steady stream of revenue. While they may not have the same profit margins as the stars, they still play a crucial role in driving your business forward. Don't underestimate their power! 

Keep these dishes fresh and enticing by periodically updating their descriptions or offering limited-time promotions to further boost their sales.

Puzzles: the enigmatic enigmas

Enter the realm of culinary mysteries—the puzzle menu items. These dishes have moderate sales but somehow fail to reach their full profit potential. They leave you scratching your head, wondering why they haven't achieved star status. It's time to channel your inner detective and unlock the secrets of these enigmatic menu items. 

Explore various strategies such as adjusting their prices, refining their descriptions, or even giving them a makeover to enhance their appeal. Solving the puzzle and transforming these dishes into profitable winners will not only delight your customers but also boost your restaurant's overall performance.

Dogs: when it's time to say goodbye

In every menu's journey, there may come a time when certain dishes just don't make the cut. Enter the dogs—the underperforming menu items that struggle to attract customers or generate profits. While it can be tough to bid farewell to these culinary companions, sometimes it's necessary to make room for more successful ventures. 

Evaluate whether these menu items can be revamped or if it's time to let them gracefully exit the stage. Don't be disheartened! Clearing out the dogs from your menu allows you to focus on the stars, plowhorses, and puzzles that have the potential to skyrocket your profits.

In the world of menu engineering, understanding the four categories—stars, plowhorses, puzzles, and dogs—unleashes your menu maverick skills. Embrace the stars and give them the spotlight they deserve, appreciate the reliability of your plowhorses, challenge yourself to solve the puzzle menu items, and have the courage to bid farewell to the underperforming dogs. 

By harnessing the power of these categories, you can elevate your menu's performance, increase profitability, and leave your customers begging for an encore. Let the menu engineering magic begin!

Take Control with a Responsive Restaurant POS

Host with confidence when you rely on Epos Now’s dedicated restaurant POS. Process multichannel sales (from in-house, takeaway, and delivery) all in one place!

Get your offer

Menu engineering techniques and strategies: elevating your menu mastery

This section will unveil a repertoire of powerful techniques and strategies that can skyrocket your restaurant's profitability and popularity. Let's explore each strategy and discover how they can work wonders for restaurant menus.

Menu item placement and highlighting

Imagine you own a small Italian restaurant. To captivate your customers' attention, strategically place high-profit items in the prime real estate of your menu—whether it's the top-right corner, or in a visually distinct section. 

For instance, feature your signature dish, like a mouthwatering homemade lasagna, at the very top, tempting customers to explore the rest of the menu. 

Additionally, use visual cues such as borders, bold font, photos, or icons to highlight these star items and guide your customers toward making irresistible choices.

Menu pricing psychology

In the world of menu engineering, pricing is an art form that plays with customers' perceptions. Let's say you own a small Italian restaurant and want to introduce a new gourmet pizza. 

To maximize its appeal, strategically price it slightly higher than your regular pizzas. 

(Customers will perceive it as a premium option, associating higher quality with a higher price tag.) 

However, ensure that the price increase is justified by emphasizing the gourmet ingredients and unique flavors in the description, adding to the perceived value of the dish.

Menu item descriptions and storytelling

In your cozy Italian restaurant, every dish has a story to tell. Enhance the power of your menu items with vivid descriptions that evoke emotions and cravings. 

For example, imagine describing your homemade tiramisu as "layers of velvety mascarpone cream, delicately soaked ladyfingers, and a dusting of rich cocoa—inspired by Nonna's cherished recipe." 

By adding a touch of nostalgia and personal connection, you transport your customers to the heart of Italy, making the dish irresistible.

Upselling and cross-selling techniques

Boost your restaurant's revenue by skillfully employing upselling and cross-selling techniques. 

Let's say a customer orders a classic spaghetti Bolognese in your Italian restaurant. Train your waitstaff to suggest an upgrade to a premium pasta dish like penne alla vodka or a mouthwatering meatball appetizer as a delectable addition. 

By recommending complementary items that enhance the dining experience, you not only increase sales but also introduce customers to a wider range of your culinary offerings.

Menu item size and portion control

When it comes to portion sizes, striking the right balance is key. Consider your target audience and their preferences. 

If you own a small Italian restaurant and cater to families, offering generous portions may be well-received. However, if your target market is health-conscious individuals, consider offering smaller, more portion-controlled options. 

Adjusting portion sizes allows you to optimize ingredient usage, manage food costs, and cater to different customer needs and desires.

Let your menu become a masterpiece that entices, intrigues, and leaves your customers craving for more. Get ready to witness the transformation of your menu into a culinary work of art!

Utilizing POS technology for menu engineering

In today's digital age, technology is a menu engineer's best friend! By harnessing the power of restaurant POS systems, payment processing solutions, and detailed reports, you can supercharge your menu engineering efforts and elevate your restaurant's performance to new heights. Let's dive into the world of digital possibilities!

Embrace the restaurant POS revolution

Say goodbye to the days of manual order-taking and handwritten tickets. With a modern restaurant POS system, you can revolutionize your operations and menu engineering practices - from kitchen to front of house. 

From seamless order management to efficient inventory tracking, a robust POS system becomes your trusty sidekick, ensuring accurate data collection and streamlined processes. It allows you to make data-driven menu decisions, track sales in real time, and even manage ingredients and recipes. 

Embrace this digital revolution and let your menu engineering prowess shine!

Payment processing magic

In the realm of menu engineering, payment processing technology offers a tantalizing blend of convenience and profitability. By integrating secure and efficient payment solutions, such as mobile payment apps or contactless options, you cater to the preferences of modern customers who crave seamless experiences. 

But it doesn't stop there! These payment processing tools provide valuable insights into customer behavior, transaction trends, and purchase patterns. Utilize this data to fine-tune your menu, identify popular items, and make informed decisions that maximize profitability.

Unveiling the insights

Data is the new goldmine in the menu engineering realm. Detailed reports generated by your restaurant POS system provide a wealth of information to unlock hidden opportunities. Dive into the treasure trove of sales data, menu item performance, and customer preferences. 

Identify trends, analyze customer feedback, and make data-backed adjustments to your menu. Discover which items are the true stars, optimize pricing strategies, and identify potential areas of improvement. Let these detailed reports guide your menu engineering decisions and lead you to culinary success. (And again - if you have a good POS system, it’s super easy to run these reports to make informed choices!)

By embracing technology, incorporating a reliable restaurant POS system, and leveraging advanced payment processing solutions, you unlock a world of digital possibilities for your menu engineering endeavors. Streamline your operations, offer convenient payment options, and extract valuable insights from detailed reports. Embrace the digital era and watch your menu engineering mastery reach new heights. It's time to infuse your menu with the power of technology and savor the delightful results!

Food for thought on menu engineering!

Congratulations, menu engineer extraordinaire! You've embarked on a journey to master the art and science of menu engineering. As you savor the delicious success that awaits, let's take a moment to reflect on the feast of knowledge we've devoured together.

From understanding the importance of menu design and layout to unraveling the mysteries of the four menu engineering categories, you've gained the tools to create a menu that delights both the eyes and taste buds. Pricing strategies have become your secret sauce, allowing you to strike the perfect balance between profitability and customer satisfaction. And let's not forget the power of categorizing your menu items—spotlighting the stars, appreciating the plowhorses, solving the puzzles, and bidding farewell to the dogs.

But wait, there's more! With technology by your side, you've unlocked a whole new dimension of menu engineering. By embracing restaurant POS systems, payment processing solutions, and the insights gleaned from detailed reports, you've harnessed the digital power to elevate your menu and business to unprecedented levels.

And as the world evolves, so does the art of menu engineering. Online menu engineering and menu design continue to shape the culinary landscape, enticing customers with tantalizing visuals and captivating descriptions. So, stay hungry for knowledge and adapt to the ever-changing tastes and trends of the industry.

Remember, while food is undoubtedly the heart and soul of your restaurant, menu engineering is the secret ingredient that fuels profitability. Keep a watchful eye on your food cost percentage, experiment with online menu engineering, and let your menu design be a work of art that seduces customers with its visual appeal.

Check out our additional resources below:

Learn how our Point of Sale (POS) system can revolutionize your business operations and drive growth.

By submitting your details you agree to our terms and conditions & privacy policy.